CMC Markets analyst David Taylor said the domestic market was "wandering in the wilderness", with little direction and thin trading volumes.
"Good employment data from US gave the local market a boost for the first half hour, but afterwards, it has bounced up and down," Mr Taylor said.
"Lately, we've seen the materials and energy sectors holding the market up when it's positive, but there has been very little conviction anywhere else.
"It's all over the shop today... We're having considerable problems gaining momentum.
"Most of the information we have has been already priced into the market."
Mr Taylor said he expected a minor rally around Christmas and into the New Year, supported by minerals, energy and, perhaps, finance.
At 12.02pm AEDT, BHP Billiton was up 37 cents at $41.56, while Rio Tinto had fallen 91 cents to $70.79.
"Investors have been switching out of Rio Tinto and into BHP," Mr Taylor said.
Shares weaker at noon as miners fallStocks decline in early morning trading